2024 SDCC A Conversation With Ron D. Moore

Greetings, anatomy students!

Long time – no see! 😜

As many of you know, I was at the 2024 San Diego Comic-Con last weekend. Saw a huge forest fire on the flight down. 🔥 I could see the main plume from miles away and it looked a good deal like a nuclear mushroom cloud! You can just make it out at the front of the wing. 😳

Arrived Thursday after lunch. Grabbed a shuttle that dropped me off near the Convention Center. Scrambled to the press desk, checked in, and got my Press Pass plus an ADA sticker as my ankle is not yet fully functional. 🤕

Rushed to Suite 6DE  barely making it into the event: “A Conversation With Ron D. Moore!”😅

The audience was surprised and delighted to discover the host was none other than Mary McDonnell of “Battlestar Galactica” and “Dances With Wolves” fame! You may recall, Mary played the part of President Laura Roslin on Galactica.

 

She greeted us with her melodious and resonant voice and soon invited the guest of honor to join her.

It was Ron D. Moore, himself! This is her brief introduction of Ron.

Mary welcomed Ron and told him how much she enjoyed working with him on Battlestar.  She then began a series of thoughtful questions which he answered with his usual frankness and candor.

She asked Ron if his ability to write strong women is an indication of feminism. He is not sure but he has empathy for women. I found the following part quite interesting as Mary queried Ron about writing parts for strong women in the face of power.  She complimented him for being able to do this as few men show such talent and insight.  She also praised him for writing equally strong men.

I wondered if he writes strong women intuitively, and not necessarily by plan. He said he enjoys writing parts for strong women. He talked about the process of getting a female captain (Captain Janeway) onto Star Trek: Voyager. He also said he puts himself in women’s shoes which is always a winning strategy, imo. 🤩

Mary asked Ron about shutting off the creative process when he is not at work.  He doesn’t really do that. He is able to leave work and concentrate on other things but running in the background is always something that his brain is working on. He warned about getting totally immersed as a show runner because there is no limit to the amount of involvement that can engulf one.

In this last and final clip, Mary asked Ron about the great love between Jamie and Claire throughout their different lives and across time.  Ron agrees that Diana Gabaldon wrote the perfect love story of two people who found their soul mates. although it is a wonderful concept, he is not sure true love  is real and that there is only one soul mate for each of us. Mary loves the story of Jamie and Claire because it gives us hope. She is a solid fan of Outlander! 🥰

She ended the session with a huge hug for Ron. Clearly, she carries a lot of affection for him and their time working together!

I hope you enjoyed this review of Ron’s conversation with Mary. It was enlightening for me, especially Ron explaining that Outlander time has come to end. We who disagree will continue to read the books!  👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

“So say we all!” 😉

The deeply grateful,

Outlander Anatomist

Follow me on:

Photo and video credits: www.wikipedia.com, Outlander Anatomy

Anatomy Lesson: Mandy’s Malady

Welcome all anatomy students! It has been a while since I posted a lesson because, frankly, I have been dealing with my own malady – a shattered left ankle! Six months out and beginning to feel and function better. 🥳

Outlander fans recall that in episode Episode 702, “The Happiest Place on Earth,” Brianna gives birth to her second child, Amanda Hope Claire MacKenzie-Fraser. Dr. Claire is there to reassure Brianna and ease the process. The wee one is adored by all and affectionately nicknamed, Mandy.  Fraser’s Ridge is the happiest place on earth and all is well! 🥰

Young Mandy is quickly introduced to the Ridge’s denizens as Granda’ Jamie takes her on a wee stroll to meet a new foal at the stable. Do you see it, Mandy? It is a cutie-beauty like you! 😍 

Mandy’s doting Granny takes her on a guided tour of Claire’s fav room – the surgery! Mayhap she will follow in Granny’s footsteps? 👩🏻‍⚕️

Claire coos to Mandy, admiring the beautiful, wee lass. Then…. she sees Mandy’s fingernails. A closer look and a startled Claire exclaims: “Bloody hell!”  (Couldn’t have said it better myself)  

Ever observant Claire spies a bluish tinge at the base of Mandy’s wee fingernails (below, red arrows)!

Fun Fact: This is not hyperbole.  Fingernails and toenails give clues to at least a dozen possible medical conditions that require evaluation and followup. And, Mandy is no exception.

A quote from Diana’s 6th big book, “A Breath of Snow and Ashes,” documents the moment Claire observes Mandy’s nail beds: ”

“The minute nails were faintly tinged with blue.” 

Bree senses Claire’s concern and asks what is wrong.  She kens that look on her mother’s face. After Claire explains, Bree reports her own maternal observations: Mandy does not nurse well nor is she gaining weight like Jem. What is wrong? 😯

Claire determines that the wee lass has a heart defect requiring more advanced care than Claire is able to provide in the 1700s. She is clear that Mandy’s Malady is life-threatening and she likely will not survive for long without corrective cardiac surgery. Brianna and Roger decide to return with their children to the 20th century to obtain the necessary care to save Mandy’s life.

Arrangements are made for the MacKenzie family to travel through time at the standing stones on Ocracoke Island. Everyone agrees this is the best course of action, but this time and place is no longer the “happiest place on earth!” Will they ever see Fraser’s Ridge and one another again? 🤷🏻‍♀️

Time to start our lesson….What leads Claire to her startling diagnosis? The following are symptoms and clues that Doctor Claire considered:

    • Lethargy and weakness
    • Fast or labored breathing
    • Tachycardia (a heart rate exceeding the normal resting rate)
    • Cyanosis (blue-ish skin color due to a lack of oxygen), primarily seen in lower extremities
    • Dyspnea (shortness of breath)
    • Poor feeding
    • Failure to thrive
    • Distinctive murmur

Another pithy quote from “A Breath of Snow and Ashes:” 

I moved my stethoscope over the tiny chest, ear pressed to it, listening intently. It was my best stethoscope, a model from the nineteenth century called a Pinard—a bell with a flattened disc at one end, to which I pressed my ear. I had one carved of wood; this one was made of pewter; Brianna had sand-cast it for me.

The following image is a wooden Pinard stethoscope, currently for sale on the Internet for about $180 (there are much less expensive versions)! 💰

Claire placed her ear against the cup shaped disc at the top; the bottom of the tube was placed on Mandy’s chest. The stethoscope amplifies the sounds of blood rushing through the heart and striking its valves.  

What did Claire listen for? she was listening for a distinctive murmur: a soft, continuous shushing sound, particularly audible near the base of the neck. It is usually the first diagnostic sign of a problem with a fetal heart vessel.  

Although Mandy exhibits only some of the above symptoms, Claire diagnoses Mandy’s condition as a Patent Ductus Arteriosus (PDA).  

But, before we can understand PDA, let’s look at normal heart anatomy.

Heart Anatomy: To better understand Mandy’s Malady, let’s consider the normal anatomy of the heart and its great vessels. Now, I kid you not, the heart is a very complex organ, both anatomically (structure) and physiologically (function). We will only cover the basics. Understand that there are many more anatomical details that are beyond the scope of this lesson. But, we fearless folk press onward!

Chambers: The human heart has four chambers (next image). Right atrium and left atrium are thin-walled filling chambers. Right ventricle and left ventricle are thick-walled pumping chambers . The walls are composed of cardiac muscle, a specialized tissue found in the heart. (psst….don’t forget, the patient’s left is your right, and vice versa) 🤓 

Vessels: The heart has eight (!!!) vessels carrying blood to and from its chambers. These are (next image):

    • Superior vena cava – delivers blood from upper body into right atrium
    • Inferior vena cava – delivers blood from lower body into right atrium
    • Pulmonary artery – deliver blood from right ventricle to lungs
    • Four pulmonary veins – deliver blood from lungs to left atrium
    • Aorta – delivers blood from left ventricle to body 

Blood Flow: Next, let’s review the pattern of blood flow through the heart. As you read the details, check with the image below to verify the flow.

    • Deoxygenated blood (low oxygen – O2; high carbon dioxide -CO2) from  superior vena cava and inferior vena cava pours into right atrium and then into right ventricle.
    • Right ventricle contracts and ejects blood into the pulmonary artery which branches to supply left and right lungs. 
    • Blood releases carbon dioxide (CO2) in the lungs which is exhaled and picks up O2 from inhaled air.
    • Oxygenated blood (O2-rich) is carried to left atrium via four pulmonary veins. 
    • Blood pours into the left ventricle which contracts and ejects O2-rich blood into the aorta.
    • Branches of aorta carry blood to all other regions of the body (except lungs).  

OK, students, hang in there! With normal anatomy under our belt, let’s look at the fetal circulation. 

Fetal Circulation: Blood circulation in the fetus is different because the placenta provides the functions of lungs, gastrointestinal tract, and kidneys. Thus, a normal blood supply to these maturing organs is not required.

Ductus Arteriosus: The fetal heart has a vascular bridge between pulmonary artery and aorta that shunts blood exiting the right ventricle into the aorta and bypasses the lungs. This vascular bridge is the muscular ductus arteriosus (aqua arrow – below image). Again, because lungs do not process gasses during intrauterine life, most blood is shunted away from them. 

The ductus arteriorsus is patent (open) throughout fetal life and normally closes within 24 hours after birth as blood flow to the lungs is established. Within 2-3 weeks, it turns into a fibrous band, the ligamentum arteriosum. 

All of this is highly regulated by various chemical and physiological substances including oxygen levels. 

Patent Ductus Arteriosus: If the ductus arteriosus does not close soon after birth but remains patent (open), it is diagnosed as PDA, a congenital heart lesion. PDAs are most common in premature babies but can also occur with full term infants. 

Nowdays, if a ductus arteriosus does not spontaneously close after 8 weeks post-birth, it usually is treated with medications, plugged, or surgically closed. Small PDAs may not be a cause for concern and are often not treated.

Adding a bit of perspective – PDA is not new. It was known as early as 129 A.D. to Galen, a Greek anatomist and physician, although he didn’t understand its significance. It wasn’t until 1938, almost two millennia later, that Dr. Robert E. Gross of Harvard Medical School and Children’s Hospital in Boston, Massachusetts, perform the first successful ligation (closure) of a PDA. This was also the first congenital heart lesion to be successful corrected, surgically.

Now, let’s return to Mandy’s Malady. This was her problem. Mandy’s ductus arteriosus did not close after birth and she exhibited some of the concerning symptoms outlined above.  Blood from her aorta flooded her lungs subjecting fragile lung tissues to excessive blood pressure (hypertension). Allowed to go unchecked, the fragile lungs will be permanently damaged and she  eventually will experience right-sided heart failure.

Diana explains all of this with her usual magical writing skills in this excerpt from “A Breath of Snow and Ashes:” 

The ductus arteriosus is a small blood vessel that in the fetus joins the aorta to the pulmonary artery. Babies have lungs, of course, but prior to birth don’t use them; all their oxygen comes from the placenta, via the umbilical cord. Ergo, no need for blood to be circulated to the lungs, save to nourish the developing tissue—and so the ductus arteriosus bypasses the pulmonary circulation. 

At birth, though, the baby takes its first breath, and oxygen sensors in this small vessel cause it to contract—and close permanently. With the ductus arteriosus closed, blood heads out from the heart to the lungs, picks up oxygen, and comes back to be pumped out to the rest of the body. A neat and elegant system—save that it doesn’t always work properly.

The ductus arteriosus doesn’t always close. If it doesn’t, blood still does go to the lungs, of course—but the bypass is still there. Too much blood goes to the lungs, in some cases, and floods them. The lungs swell, become congested, and with diverted blood flow to the body, there are problems with oxygenation—which can become acute.

Lastly, this is a brief video about PDA which you might find useful. It is easy to understand and accurate: https://youtu.be/7DKaCqubuSg. 🤓

Fast forward! It is clear that the MacKenzies arrived safely in the 20th Century and Mandy received the medical intervention needed for her PDA repair. When we meet her next at Lallybroch, she is a healthy, happy, and feisty wee lass, played by Rosa Morris. 🤗

As William Shakespeare once wrote, “All’s Well That Ends Well!”

(Well, it would end better if they were all together, but we shall see) 🤞🏻

The deeply grateful,

Outlander Anatomist

Follow me on:

Photo creds: Sony/Starz; www.commons.wikimedia.org; www.heart.org; www.kidshealth.com; www.medicalsuppliesgh.com; www.medlineplus.gov; www.outlander.fandom.com; www.theoutlandermuse.com; www.twitter.com (now X)

Anatomy Mini-Lesson – Popliteal Aneurysm!

Greetings Outlander anatomy students!

Much time has passed since my last post partly because I am nursing broken bones of my left ankle. I am working off an iPad, instead of my desktop computer, so it is slow going. 😱

Today’s lesson details Mr. Walter Woodcock’s dilemma as presented in Outlander episode 705, Singapore.

You will recall, Walter lies in the infirmary at Fort Ticonderoga with a significant injury to his right foot. The wound has turned gangrenous so an amputation is required.

Claire arrives to witness a medical dispute between Dr. Denzel Hunter and the pompous, Lieutenant Stactoe.

Curious Claire asks, what is going on? 🤔

Denzel recommends an above-knee amputation for Walter. Stactoe is adamant that a below-knee amputation makes for a more functional limb.

Stactoe is correct that in most circumstances, every attempt is made to salvage as much of a limb as is possible.

However, Denzel explains that Walter has a popliteal aneurysm, thus, an above-the-knee amputation is necessary! Claire palpates Walter’s calf and agrees with Denny.

Oh, oh! This changes everything! 🤔

There ensues a wee strammash when Stactoe says Claire will not use boiling water on HIS instruments. This is a direct quote from Diana’s An Echo in the Bone:

You will ruin the temper of the metal, subjecting it to boiling water!”

“No,” I said, keeping my own temper—for the moment. “Hot water will do nothing but clean it. And I will not use a dirty blade on this man.”

“Oh, won’t you?” Something like satisfaction glimmered in his eyes, and he clutched the blade protectively to his bosom.”

In the episode, Stactoe stomps off. But, no worries, Denzel to the rescue with his own set of fine surgical instruments!

To understand the implications of a popliteal artery aneurysm, let’s look at the anatomy of the arterial supply to the knee.

Essentially all of the lower limb is supplied by the huge femoral artery which begins at the groin and descends through the front of thigh. Near the top of the knee, the artery passes to the back of the knee and is renamed the popliteal artery (next figure). It then descends behind the knee joint. At the bottom of the joint, it splits into two and then into a third artery, all of which receive new names and supply lower leg and foot.

The hollow behind the knee joint is the popliteal fossa.

Try This:  Make a fist, bend opposite knee slightly, and tuck your fist into the hollow behind your knee. This is the popliteal fossa. Remove your fist and insert middle and ring fingers into the hollow. Press. You may be able to feel the pulsing of the popliteal artery in the popliteal fossa.

Feel it? Good job, students! 🤗

   
Next. The aneurysm! 🤓

A popliteal artery aneurysm, known by the acronym PAA, is a weak spot in the wall of the popliteal artery. Pressure exerted by arterial blood causes the weak spot to balloon into a palpable bulge behind the knee joint. This is of concern because if the aneurysm should burst, the blood loss would be difficult to control especially in an amputee.

Some causes of PAA are:

  • Atherosclerosis
  • High blood pressure
  • Wear and tear of the popliteal artery due to over use of knee joint
  • Weakening of the artery wall

The image show a couple different types of PAA.


Now, back to the episode!

Claire palpates Walter’s leg and agrees with Denzel. An above-knee amputation is best to avoid the aneurysm bursting with uncontrolled hemorrhaging.

A clear view of his damaged, gangrenous foot can be seen in the next image.

Unfortunately, Claire places her hands on either side of his calf. She cannot feel a PAA in this location because there is no popliteal artery behind the calf. Her hands should be up in the hollow of the knee.

Nevertheless, she gets an A+ for trying! 🤩

Also, in real life, the stench of gangrene would likely require them to mask and use some type of ointment under the nose to distract from the odor. 😮

And, today, imaging modalities would be used to determine the type and extent of a PAA.

In the final scene with Walter, Claire breaks the sad news that his condition does not permit him to be evacuated with the other patients.  He is to be left behind. 😢

Claire has a wonderful bedside manner which comes from her compassionate and caring heart. Hopefully,  the British will treat Walter well. 🤞🏻

Mercy! 😉

I hope you enjoyed today’s lesson. Just remember, if you ever feel a pulsing bulge behind  the knee, make an appointment swiftly or get into urgent care. A PAA is no joke!

The deeply grateful,

Outlander Anatomist

Follow me on:

Photo creds: Sony/Starz, www.myclevelandclinic.org, www.uptodate.com